Food & Drink

Key Lime Heaven: Our Top 13 Picks for the Best Slice in Austin!

Are you a fan of tangy, sweet, and creamy desserts? Then you must try the key lime pie! This Florida classic has made its way to Austin, and there are plenty of places to indulge in this delicious treat.

But where can you find the best key lime pie? Fear not, as we have scoured the city to bring you the top spots.

Whether you're a local or a tourist, you'll find something to love about the key lime pies in Austin. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to decide where to start.

Some places offer traditional key lime pies with a graham cracker crust, while others put their own spin on the dessert with unique ingredients and toppings. From classic to creative, Austin has a key lime pie for everyone.

But what makes a great key lime pie? Some may argue that the filling should be tart but not too sour, while others prefer a sweeter taste. The crust should be buttery and crumbly, and the whipped cream should be light and fluffy.

These are just a few factors that contribute to a fantastic key lime pie. So, without further ado, let's dive into the top places to get your fix of this delectable dessert in Austin.

1. Cherrywood Coffeehouse

Cherrywood Coffeehouse
1400 E 38th 1/2 St, Austin, TX 78722 (Google Maps)

Cherrywood Coffeehouse is a must-visit spot for key lime pie lovers. The pie is tangy, sweet, and perfectly balanced.

The crust is flaky and adds a nice texture to the pie. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is cozy and inviting.

The outdoor patio is a great place to enjoy a slice of pie with a cup of coffee. The coffee is freshly brewed and pairs well with the pie.

The prices are reasonable and the portions are generous. If you're in the mood for a delicious slice of key lime pie, Cherrywood Coffeehouse is the place to be.

2. Upper Crust Bakery

Upper Crust Bakery
4508 Burnet Rd, Austin, TX 78756 (Google Maps)

Upper Crust Bakery is a must-visit for anyone looking for delicious key lime pie.

This well-known bakery offers a cozy ambiance and serves made-from-scratch pastries, bread, and lunch fare. The staff is friendly and accommodating, and the prices are reasonable.

The key lime pie is a standout item on the menu, with a perfect balance of sweet and tart flavors.

Upper Crust Bakery is the perfect spot to satisfy your sweet tooth cravings and enjoy a delicious slice of key lime pie.

3. Bartlett's Restaurant

Bartlett's Restaurant
2408 W Anderson Ln., Austin, TX 78757 (Google Maps)

Looking for the best key lime pie in town, look no further than Bartlett's Restaurant. Their key lime pie is a must-try for dessert enthusiasts.

The restaurant offers a cozy and intimate atmosphere, making it perfect for a romantic dinner.

The service is top-notch and the staff is friendly and attentive.

Bartlett's also offers a variety of other delicious dishes and quality drinks. Don't miss out on this gem of a restaurant.

4. Quack's 43rd Street Bakery

Quack's 43Rd Street Bakery
411 E 43rd St, Austin, TX 78751 (Google Maps)

If you're in the mood for some delicious key lime pie, look no further than Quack's 43rd Street Bakery.

This cozy bakery offers a wide variety of baked goods, but their key lime pie is a standout.

The filling is perfectly tart and creamy, with a buttery graham cracker crust that complements it perfectly.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, Quack's is a must-visit for any dessert lover.

5. Sawyer & Co

Sawyer & Co
4827 E Cesar Chavez St, Austin, TX 78702 (Google Maps)

Sawyer & Co is a contemporary Louisiana restaurant that serves some of the best key lime pie in town.

The pie is made with fresh ingredients and has the perfect balance of sweet and tangy flavors.

The restaurant has a funky and authentic vibe, and the staff is friendly and welcoming.

Sawyer & Co is a great place to satisfy your sweet tooth and enjoy a slice of delicious key lime pie.

6. Capital City Bakery

Capital City Bakery
2211 E Cesar Chavez St, Austin, TX 78702 (Google Maps)

Looking for a bakery that serves delicious vegan treats in town, Capital City Bakery is the place to be.

They offer an extensive selection of vegan cupcakes, brownies, and special-occasion cakes that are perfect for those who want to indulge in cruelty-free desserts.

Their vegan cheesecake is a must-try, with its rich and creamy texture. But what really sets them apart is their key lime pie, which is simply divine.

If you're in the mood for some sweet treats that are both delicious and ethical, Capital City Bakery is a must-visit for you.

7. Chez Zee American Bistro

Chez Zee American Bistro
5406 Balcones Dr, Austin, TX 78731 (Google Maps)

Chez Zee American Bistro is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. Their key lime pie is a standout dessert, perfectly tart and creamy with a crumbly graham cracker crust.

But the dessert menu doesn't stop there – indulge in their peanut butter pie or lemon rosemary cake for a truly decadent experience.

The bistro also offers a diverse menu with options for every budget, and the ambiance is cozy and inviting.

Don't miss out on this hidden gem for a sweet treat in a charming setting.

8. Pie Bar

Pie Bar
8900 S Congress Ave Bldg 2, #150, Austin, TX 78745 (Google Maps)

Pie Bar is a charming little pie and dessert shop that offers a variety of delectable treats.

Their key lime pie is a must-try – it's perfectly balanced and smooth.

The GF crust options are great for those with dietary restrictions. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the prices are reasonable.

If you're in the mood for something sweet, Pie Bar is definitely worth a visit.

9. Lady Quackenbush's Cakery

Lady Quackenbush's Cakery
1900 Simond Ave #300, Austin, TX 78723 (Google Maps)

Lady Quackenbush's Cakery is a must-visit for anyone looking for delicious key lime pie.

This bakery offers a variety of pastries, cakes, and cupcakes that are simply divine. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the atmosphere is cozy and inviting.

Customers rave about the quality and affordability of their baked goods, with many mentioning the moist and fluffy texture of their cakes.

Vegan and gluten-free options are available, making it a great spot for those with dietary restrictions. Lady Quackenbush's Cakery is a gem in the city, and definitely worth a visit for anyone with a sweet tooth.

10. Side Eye Pie

Side Eye Pie
3901 Promontory Point Dr, Austin, TX 78744 (Google Maps)

Located in a bustling food truck park, Side Eye Pie serves up some of Austin's best pizza.

But don't overlook their key lime pie, which is a tangy, creamy delight.

The crust is buttery and the filling is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness.

It's a must-try for any dessert lover in the area.

11. Russell's Bakery & Coffee

Russell's Bakery & Coffee
3339 Hancock Dr, Austin, TX 78731 (Google Maps)

Looking for the best key lime pie in town but tired of the usual spots in Austin, Texas, then try Russell's Bakery & Coffee.

This hidden gem is a relaxed bakery with patio seating, crafting made-from-scratch baked goods and espresso drinks.

Their key lime pie is a must-try, and it's definitely worth the price.

The friendly staff and the cozy atmosphere make it a perfect spot for a quick break, a business meeting, or a casual lunch.

12. Red River Cafe

Red River Cafe
2912 Medical Arts St, Austin, TX 78705 (Google Maps)

If you're looking for a cozy American diner that serves up a mean slice of key lime pie, Red River Cafe might just be the spot for you.

This family-friendly restaurant offers a variety of classic breakfast and lunch dishes, but the real star of the show is their tangy and creamy key lime pie.

With a homey atmosphere and friendly staff, Red River Cafe is the perfect place to indulge in a slice of dessert after a satisfying meal.

13. Sugar Mama's Bakeshop

Sugar Mama's Bakeshop
1905 S 1st St, Austin, TX 78704 (Google Maps)

Sugar Mama's Bakeshop is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth.

Their key lime pie is a standout, with a tangy and creamy filling that is perfectly balanced. The crust is flaky and buttery, adding a delicious crunch to each bite.

The bakery also offers a wide variety of other desserts, including cupcakes, cookies, and bars, all made with high-quality ingredients and a personal touch.

The vintage space is cozy and welcoming, making it the perfect spot to indulge in a sweet treat. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Sugar Mama's Bakeshop is not to be missed.